Film Discussion thread

I watched Prevenge on a flight recently. It's basically about a pregnant woman who's unborn child makes her kill lots of people to somehow avenge the death of her boyfriend/baby's father. It's no classic but was enjoyable enough and quite funny in places.

 
You are seriously weird @bluedave! 

To return to the fray on kids' films or not kids' films, I am genuinely bemused by any adult who tells me he has read all the Harry Potter books and loves them. I usually answer very politely, with a phrase like "Oh, that's nice." or " Mmm, lovely!" I can't get my head round why an adult would want to do that, when there are so many brilliant books for adults around.

 
It's not bad but it's certainly very meh. Johnson threw everything Star Wars fan-boys know and love about the franchise out of the window and made it his own...which, wasn't the cleverest thing to do in hindsight.

There are some really stupid bits in it and poor John Boyega, who was so terrific on TFA, had little to do apart from a side quest to Las Vegas. Johnson reinterprets what the Force means/what it can do which made one moment in particular seem f**king stupid. That said, there are a couple of cool scenes.
There’s so much bad writing in it.

Never in 8 previous films had the concept of the ships running low on fuel been an issue and now suddenly it’s affecting and entire fleet?

Suddenly new force abilities are springing up left right and centre. Nearly all the groundwork layed in Force Awakens is ignored, that Luke left a map to find him is completely ignored in favour of cringeworthy slapstick humour.

Changing directors during a trilogy is just bemusing. The tone is all over the place and it’s resulted in something nothing short of a complete train wreck. 

 
There’s so much bad writing in it.

Never in 8 previous films had the concept of the ships running low on fuel been an issue and now suddenly it’s affecting and entire fleet?

Suddenly new force abilities are springing up left right and centre. Nearly all the groundwork layed in Force Awakens is ignored, that Luke left a map to find him is completely ignored in favour of cringeworthy slapstick humour.

Changing directors during a trilogy is just bemusing. The tone is all over the place and it’s resulted in something nothing short of a complete train wreck. 
Hard to argue with any of that! 

 
You are seriously weird @bluedave! 

To return to the fray on kids' films or not kids' films, I am genuinely bemused by any adult who tells me he has read all the Harry Potter books and loves them. I usually answer very politely, with a phrase like "Oh, that's nice." or " Mmm, lovely!" I can't get my head round why an adult would want to do that, when there are so many brilliant books for adults around.
I'm one of those adults  :smile:  And I read other books as well. One doesn't preclude the other, but I'm sure you know that  :wink:

 
I'm one of those adults  :smile:  And I read other books as well. One doesn't preclude the other, but I'm sure you know that  :wink:
Of course I know that, after all I know everything, don't I?  But I don't understand it, which is not the same.  And I don't understand how someone who has a full time job has the time to read so many books! (as well as watch footie and drink beer!)

When I was a kid, I read Biggles books and Just William books! That's how ancient I am!

 
I liked the Harry Potter books also.   Though reading each book took me weeks, especially the super-sized last few books.  The escapism of the totally different Hogwarts universe gave it a sci-fi feel that I liked for some weird reason, even though I am not really into sci-fi novels. 

Upon some more thinking about it, I loved JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings books, and I suppose JK Rowling is a poor-man's Tolkien in some respects.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I liked the Harry Potter books also.   Though reading each book took me weeks, especially the super-sized last few books.  The escapism of the totally different Hogwarts universe gave it a sci-fi feel that I liked for some weird reason, even though I am not really into sci-fi novels. 

Upon some more thinking about it, I loved JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings books, and I suppose JK Rowling is a poor-man's Tolkien in some respects.
Oh to be a poor-man's anything looking at the fortune she has amassed!

 
I liked the Harry Potter books also.   Though reading each book took me weeks, especially the super-sized last few books.  The escapism of the totally different Hogwarts universe gave it a sci-fi feel that I liked for some weird reason, even though I am not really into sci-fi novels. 

Upon some more thinking about it, I loved JRR Tolkien's Lord of the Rings books, and I suppose JK Rowling is a poor-man's Tolkien in some respects.
If you liked LOTR it is well worth reading the Silmarillion. I hear they are now making productions around some of the stories like Beren and Luthien.

 
Thought I'd resurrect this thread to ask if anyone's seen the Shape of Water?  Just got back from seeing it and a bit bemused by it really.  I enjoyed it but it was very silly and weird - a bit like a 50s B movie monster film but with lots of money and special effects.  All a bit surreal.  But Best Picture? I haven't seen the others but if that's the best film of the last year, I'd be surprised.
Yeah.. I have seen all best picture nominees of the last oscars I think. The Shape of Water was all right, nothing special though. I thought ''Three Billboards'' was by far the best, if you haven't seen it yet, do. It is a Martin Mcdonough movie who also made "In Bruges'' and ''Seven Psychopaths'', in case you haven't seen them, do;). That man is a great director, really cool films. Dunkirk was also amazing, way better than the Shape of Water, at least in my opinion. I really didn't get what the fuss was about to be honest. 

 
Has anyone here ever seen an excellent film from the nineteen nineties called At Play In The Fields Of The Lord?

 
Yeah.. I have seen all best picture nominees of the last oscars I think. The Shape of Water was all right, nothing special though. I thought ''Three Billboards'' was by far the best, if you haven't seen it yet, do. It is a Martin Mcdonough movie who also made "In Bruges'' and ''Seven Psychopaths'', in case you haven't seen them, do;). That man is a great director, really cool films. Dunkirk was also amazing, way better than the Shape of Water, at least in my opinion. I really didn't get what the fuss was about to be honest. 
I liked Bruges and have seen the Shape of Water and similarly thought it was interesting yet over-rated.

I've been meaning to see Three Billboards for a while now so good to hear your take.

 
So, considering it has Jack Nicholson in it, and the description sounded interesting, I thought I'd give As Good As It Gets a go.

Wow has that not aged well... and I don't mean in the special effects sense.

 
Back
Top