IMDB top 250

MayosNoun

First Team Squad
Messages
1,997
Reaction score
167
How many have you seen?

I haven't seen any of the following;

Godfather movies.

Schindlers List

Psycho

Any of the old westerns.

/monthly_08_2015/post-12894-0-63398000-1439372456_thumb.jpg

 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    158.1 KB · Views: 0
I've seen 123 apparently. 

I find the IMDB rating system pretty flawed personally but that's another story. 

 
Your Results

????

115 of 250 movies

46%

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interstellar, Forrest Gump and Matrix in the top 20 of all time? Ok...

 
I take ratings on things like IMDB and Rotten Tomatoes with a pinch of salt tbh.

What is good for someone else might be rubbish for you and vice versa.

 
I take ratings on things like IMDB and Rotten Tomatoes with a pinch of salt tbh.

What is good for someone else might be rubbish for you and vice versa.
It's a pretty good measure for whether something is good or bad though. 

The issue with IMDB is that you'll get things like La Haine on the list which has only 91,000 votes but then films such as Godfather or Dark Knight which have closer to 1.5m votes on it. 

I think they only count the votes of particular members of the site but there is a slight snobbery towards certain films which are highly ranked due to certain people voting on them. 

 
I've seen 116.  Possibly.  There were some I couldn't remember whether I'd seen or not so I left them out. 

 
It's a pretty good measure for whether something is good or bad though. 

The issue with IMDB is that you'll get things like La Haine on the list which has only 91,000 votes but then films such as Godfather or Dark Knight which have closer to 1.5m votes on it. 

I think they only count the votes of particular members of the site but there is a slight snobbery towards certain films which are highly ranked due to certain people voting on them. 
I don't like their rating system, but if you ask me, La Haine is a better movie than Dark Knight. Dark Knight is the only movie in the trilogy that (just about) deserves a place in the top 250, though. Maybe...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't like their rating system, but if you ask me, La Haine is a better movie than Dark Knight. Dark Knight is the only movie in the trilogy that (just about) deserves a place in the top 250, though. Maybe...
Obviously like anything in life the idea of what is "good" is always subjective. 

I just thinks it's a flawed system when something that receives 1/10 of the number of votes as most other films on the list can be ranked so highly. 

I liked La Haine but wasn't blown away by it... Doesn't help that I had to study it though I suppose. 

 
Piss poor 49 of 250.

I agree with the number 1 film but they made an error with Beauty and the Beast, they put it in the 200-and-something range rather than the 2nd spot. Easy typo to make, I best contact them to bring their obvious error to their attention.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Obviously like anything in life the idea of what is "good" is always subjective. 

I just thinks it's a flawed system when something that receives 1/10 of the number of votes as most other films on the list can be ranked so highly. 

I liked La Haine but wasn't blown away by it... Doesn't help that I had to study it though I suppose. 
I'm not familiar with their ranking system, but is it a x/10 type of system? Maybe La Haine benefits from being ranked by fewer people, but those few people who have seen it have given it a high ranking. The movies with more votes get a bigger percentage of lower rankings. Maybe that's it... Or do they really pick and choose whose ranking matters?

As for studying a movie, I remember back in school when we started doing our analysis for the movie analysis course, we were warned not to pick a movie that we liked because we'd end up hating it. I picked Rashomon, because at the time I'd not seen it. I liked it the first time I saw it, but... :happy001:

 
Piss poor 49 of 250.

I agree with the number 1 film but they made an error with Beauty and the Beast, they put it in the 200-and-something range rather than the 2nd spot. Easy typo to make, I best contact them to bring their obvious error to their attention.
/monthly_08_2015/post-12894-0-54615400-1439381256_thumb.jpg

 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    7.8 KB · Views: 0
Last edited by a moderator:
I agree with the number 1 film.
It's a good movie, but I wouldn't say it's the all time greatest. It probably should've won the Oscar that year instead of Forrest Gump, though. Then again, Four Weddings and a Funeral was probably the only nominee that year that would have deserved to win it less than Forrest Gump... :happy001:

 
75, haven't really seen any of the pre 1960's ones, they don't really interest me.

 
Back
Top